Woman asks Gladstone cops to help with her dogs. Then she opened fire on them.
Published 10:00 am Thursday, January 20, 2022
- New details from a Nov. 22 shooting emerged in a hearing in Clackamas County Circuit Court.
As Yvette Lares Garcia got into the back of a Gladstone police patrol car after her arrest one evening last fall, she told the officer she was worried about her dogs.
Gladstone Officer Clement Lau first needed to take care of Garcia’s arrest. Later, he’d deal with the dilemma of her dogs.
Back at the police station, Lau and Gladstone Sgt. Travis Hill talked with Garcia about her pets as she sat handcuffed to a bench in a hallway.
Garcia, 36, told them she had recently moved to Oregon. She said she didn’t know anyone who could care for them. They were friendly, she assured them. Everyone loved them, she said.
The cops didn’t want the animals to suffer.
And that is how two veteran police officers found themselves in a gunfight in the home of a woman who had earlier been stopped for a mundane traffic violation in Clackamas County.
The shooting left Garcia hospitalized, and Hill suffered serious injuries.
New details from the Nov. 22 shooting emerged in a hearing Tuesday in Clackamas County Circuit Court.
Garcia faces multiple counts of attempted murder or aggravated murder, first-degree assault and unlawful use of a weapon.
The Clackamas County District Attorney’s Office sought to have Garcia held without bail or held on $750,000 bail and be required to post the full amount.
“You see how intentional she is, how manipulative she is and how deceiving she is,” First Assistant Clackamas County District Attorney Scott Healy told Judge Cody Weston.
Garcia’s lawyer, Michael Romano, sought Garcia’s release on bail on $250,000 while her case is pending.
He argued that Garcia, who had moved here from Odessa, Texas, for work and had no violent history, poses no public safety threat at this point and fired that night in “an attempt to get herself killed.”
One of her friends, Greg Schwartz, testified that Garcia worked in finance at DaBella, a home construction company in Hillsboro.
Ordinary traffic stop
Lau testified about what started as an ordinary traffic stop just before 8 p.m. He saw Garcia driving through a stop sign.
Lau stopped Garcia and dispatchers ran her name for potential outstanding warrants.
The search returned a hit: Garcia, it turned out, was wanted on a felony theft warrant from Texas. Detectives in Clackamas County later learned Garcia allegedly embezzled $1.4 million from an oil company in Ector County.
Lau returned to Garcia’s car and told her she was under arrest. She would be extradited to Texas to face charges, he said. By then, Hill had pulled up to help Lau.
Garcia had just come from the gym, she told him. She was still in her workout clothes.
She was handcuffed and placed in the back of Lau’s car.
At the police station, Lau testified that he and Hill eventually settled on a plan: The officers agreed to drive Garcia home, where she would help get the dogs on leashes so they could be taken to animal control.
“I explained what the plan was, how we were going to take care of the dogs,” Hill testified. He told her he didn’t want the officers’ gesture of good will to “go sideways.”
“The indication was that she was agreeing that she would be cooperative,” he said.
Lau had one more question before they headed out: Did she have any guns at home? Their conversation was captured on his body-worn camera, which was played in court.
Garcia didn’t answer, according to the video. The officers didn’t press the matter.
When they arrived at the house, the situation wasn’t what Lau expected. The dogs, a breed Garcia identified for police as XL Bully, were larger than he had assumed. His body-camera footage showed the excited animals barking as Garcia let them into the house.
One tried to nip at him, Lau said.
Hill managed to get one of the dogs on a leash, Lau testified. Lau held the leash and stayed with the dog in the garage.
Hill then headed into the house — and out of Lau’s sight — with Garcia to get the second dog.
Hill said he thought Garcia “had been pretty cooperative” so far, so he decided to let her find her own leash and collar, which she said was upstairs. The dog that was still inside the house was harder to contain, Hill said.
“I was pretty agreeable that we could go to the bedroom and retrieve that leash,” he said.
Handgun spotted
Once in the bedroom, Hill didn’t see a leash and collar, he said. At one point, Garcia made a motion to suggest that it was near the door, he said.
He glanced briefly in that direction and then noticed Garcia kneel or bend down, her hands still cuffed behind her.
At one point, the sound of a gunshot can be heard on Lau’s camera footage. Lau was still in the garage when Garcia fired.
The officers’ testimony and Lau’s body-worn camera footage show a chaotic scene.
“As she came back up with her hands behind her back, she had a handgun in her hands and turned towards me and said, ‘I am not going to jail’ or ‘I am not going back to (expletive) jail’ and then started shooting,” Hill testified. “I was totally caught off guard thinking that she was going to have the leash so I hastily tried to get out of the room.”
She fired what investigators on Tuesday testified was a 9 mm handgun, he said.
“All I could think about was that I was going to get hurt or killed,” he said.
Downstairs, Lau said he heard Hill “screaming in pain.” He called “code zero” into his radio, the signal used when officers’ lives are in danger or under attack.
Hill yelled that Garcia had a gun, Lau testified.
Over and over, the men ordered Garcia to drop the gun.
“No!” she can be heard saying on Lau’s body-worn camera recording.
Hill scrambled downstairs and additional officers arrived to arrest Garcia.
Investigators testified that the officers fired a total of 15 rounds. Garcia, they concluded, fired three.
She hit Hill twice, below his knee and in his arm, the officer testified. Garcia was struck multiple times, including in her leg, spine, arm and abdomen, according to court testimony.
During the hearing, Hill walked in with a slight limp, a sign of the lingering effects of his injury. He testified that he sustained nerve damage in his leg and is still in pain. He remains on medical leave.
Lau, who previously worked as a Portland police officer, is back on the job. He has been a police officer in Oregon since 2016. Hill has worked as a police officer since 2002.
The hearing spanned more than 10 hours.
Garcia sat next to her lawyer, her hair in two French braids and her waist and ankles in shackles. She wore black and white jail scrubs and jail-issued white sneakers. She was hospitalized as a result of her injuries, which one of her friends said left her in pain and in need of physical therapy.
She admitted under questioning by Healy that she shot Hill.
The fate of her dogs is unclear.
In the end, the judge called Garcia’s actions deceptive. She had told police she didn’t know anyone who could care for her dogs and yet a man she worked with in Hillsboro described their relationship as close, Weston said. When asked if she had a gun at home, she didn’t respond, he noted.
“If given the opportunity,” the judge said, “I am very concerned that she would run and that she would use force to avoid going back to Texas or back to jail.”
He sided with the district attorney and kept her bail at the full $750,000.